A young resident was slapped in a Mumbai hospital for saying there was no bed. Dr. Archana Baser and Dr. Neerja Bhatla discuss what doctors can do, and what must change to protect them.

The doctor is the face of a system

Dr. Bhatla began with a caution: there are two sides to every story. But she was clear about the bigger picture. When a family is angry, the anger is often aimed at the system the doctor stands for. In her words, doctors are “the innocent face of a system that they do not control.” Genuine complaints still deserve a proper hearing, but never through violence.

When there is no bed, give a way forward

A bare “no” leaves a resident helpless. The missing resource may be a bed, blood or a specialist. Dr. Bhatla proposed a master screen showing bed availability across hospitals, linked to ambulance transport. She wants it done “post-haste.” Dr. Baser added that ambulances should be directed to the right hospital from the start, so no time is lost.

Protection that works

Dr. Bhatla pointed to airlines, where everyone knows an attack on staff means a flying ban. A clear message that attackers could lose access to government healthcare would make people think twice. Dr. Baser called for the law to be revisited, since doctors are treated as easy targets.

Breaking bad news

  • Train residents to deliver it well. A smile at the wrong moment has angered families.
  • For HDU or ICU patients, name one or two team members for updates, a senior doctor or a knowledgeable senior resident. This keeps the message consistent.
  • Look after caregivers. Tell them when it is fine to take a break, before they burn out.

Small habits that lower the temperature

Delays make anger worse. If a family waits a long time and then hears “no bed”, the wait feels like the real offence. So attend promptly, and if you are busy, ask a nurse or attendant to tell relatives you are coming. Dress neatly, avoid eating or drinking tea in patient areas, and look alert day or night. In gynecology we ask strangers intimate questions, so confidence matters.

Violence is never justified, and prevention cannot rest on residents alone. Until systems catch up, pair every “no bed” with an alternative and transport, keep updates consistent, and make sure families see you are paying attention.